Undoing Fixation

Xunzi

6 ideas

  1. Every perspective obscures its complementary opposite

    Fixation works by pairs: whoever grasps desire is blinded to aversion, beginnings to endings, the distant to the near, the broad to the shallow, the ancient to the present. Because things differ, each one you attend to hides the others, so the error is not a false belief but a true part mistaken for the whole.

  2. Each rival philosopher saw one real corner

    Mozi was fixated on utility and missed the value of culture and ritual. Shenzi was fixated on law and missed the role of worthy people, Huizi on words and missed realities, and Zhuangzi on Heaven and missed the human. Each school starts from a genuine insight and fails by making it the whole Way.

  3. Emptiness, unity, stillness as mental discipline

    Emptiness means not letting what you already store block what you are about to receive. Unity means not letting knowledge of one thing interfere with knowledge of another, so you can hold several truths at once. Stillness means not letting dreams, fantasies and agitation disorder your judgment. Together these three let the mind take in the Way whole without having to forget what it knows.

  4. The mind as a basin of water

    Water left still in a basin settles its mud and becomes clear enough to reflect a face and even an eyebrow. Stir it slightly and the reflection distorts.

  5. Juanshuliang frightened to death by his shadow

    Walking under the moon, Juanshuliang saw his own shadow and took it for a ghost, then looked up at his hair and took it for a demon, and he ran home and died of fright. Xunzi sets this beside the drunk who leaps a wide ditch as if it were a gutter and the traveler who sees a crouching stone as a tiger at night. A disturbed inner state projects meaning onto evidence, and people then settle their conclusions at their most confused moment.

  6. Set everything out and weigh it

    The cure for fixation is not to reject one corner for another but to lay out all the considerations together, desire and aversion, near and far, old and new, and weigh them on a balance. That balance is the Way. Without a stable standard of weighing, a person picks up bad things as good and discards good things as bad.

Save and mark ideas in the app