To Each His Own

Leonardo Sciascia

4 ideas

1. Laurana's investigation of the pharmacist's murder

   In a 1960s Sicilian town the pharmacist Manno receives a death threat made of words cut from L'Osservatore Romano, and soon he and his hunting companion Dr. Roscio are shot. The schoolteacher Paolo Laurana traces the clipped newsprint and uncovers the real story: Roscio was the true target, killed by the lawyer Rosello, his wife's cousin and lover, whom he had been about to expose, while the threat to Manno was a decoy. Laurana is drawn in by the widow, lured away, murdered and dumped in an abandoned sulphur pit, and the town dismisses him as a fool who got what he deserved.

2. Honor-crime staging as cover for power

   A killing arranged to look like a private affair of jealousy or seduction draws investigators toward the victim's morals and away from the political or financial motive. The staged motive works because the community already believes such stories, so the cover borrows credibility from local prejudice. The question to ask is whose exposure the death actually prevented, not whose passions it seems to express.

3. The whole community knows and stays silent

   The truth the investigator works so hard to reconstruct is already common knowledge among the townspeople, clergy and notables. Their silence is not ignorance but a shared calculation that knowing and saying nothing keeps them safe and inside the network. Criminal power therefore rests on the complicity of respectable institutions such as family, Church, the professions and local politics, not on a hidden band of outlaws.

4. Reason without power is fatal naivety

   Laurana's intelligence lets him solve the crime, but he has no allies, no institutional backing and no sense of how his curiosity looks to others. In a system where knowledge is only safe when it is not acted on, an isolated intellectual pursuing truth for its own sake becomes both a threat and a target. His solitary deduction exposes him instead of protecting him.

Save and mark ideas in the app