The Healing: On the Soul

Ibn Sina

6 ideas

  1. The Floating Man in empty air

    Imagine a person created all at once, fully mature, suspended in empty air with eyes covered and limbs spread so they touch nothing and nothing touches them. They receive no sensation of their body, yet they still affirm that they exist. What they affirm, then, is something distinct from the body that is unknown to them.

  2. Self-awareness does not depend on the body

    Because a being can be certain it exists while being entirely unaware of its limbs or organs, the thing known cannot be the same as the thing unknown. The self grasped in that awareness must therefore be something other than the body. The soul is a real entity in its own right, not a property that arises from the arrangement of flesh.

  3. Nested hierarchy of the soul's powers

    The soul is defined as the first perfection of a natural body that has organs, and its powers stack in levels. The vegetative level handles nutrition, growth and reproduction. The animal level adds perception and voluntary motion, and the human rational level adds intellect, with each higher level including the powers below it.

  4. The five internal senses

    Beyond the five external senses, the brain houses five inner faculties. The common sense unifies incoming perceptions, retentive imagination stores their forms, and the compositive imagination combines them. The estimative faculty grasps non-sensory meanings, and memory preserves what estimation has grasped.

  5. Estimation perceives meanings senses cannot

    A sheep flees a wolf it has never seen because it perceives hostility, a meaning that is not a color, shape or sound. The estimative faculty extracts such intentions from sensory particulars without reasoning. This explains instinctive judgment in animals and quick, non-rational appraisal in humans.

  6. Intellect is immaterial and survives death

    Intelligible forms are universal and indivisible, so they cannot reside in a divisible bodily organ. Intellect also does not tire from strong objects the way the eye does from bright light, and it can reflect on itself. The rational soul therefore does not rely on the body to exist and does not perish when the body does.

Save and mark ideas in the app