The Earl of Louisiana

A. J. Liebling

4 ideas

1. Louisiana Read as a Levantine Polity

   Liebling interprets Louisiana politics through Mediterranean and Levantine comparisons, especially Lebanon, rather than the standard Deep South template. The state is a balance among distinct communities: Protestant hill-country North Louisiana, Catholic French South Louisiana, and New Orleans. Seen this way, its politics looks less like simple racial demagoguery and more like brokered coalitions among sectarian blocs, run by patronage, personal loyalty and theatrical oratory.

2. Race-Baiting as a Wedge Serving the Rich

   Through Earl Long, the book argues that segregationist agitation, such as the purges of Black voters from registration rolls, served wealthy interests by splitting poor whites from poor Blacks, who shared economic grievances. A populist who needs the votes of both groups has a practical reason to resist the purge. His resistance is coalition arithmetic, not moral idealism, and the race issue works to crowd out economic demands.

3. The Governor Fires His Way Out

   In 1959, after a raging speech defending Black voters' rights, Earl Long was committed to mental hospitals, a move backed by his wife and political opponents. He got out by using his powers as governor: he fired the state hospital superintendent and installed someone who would declare him sane. The episode shows that institutional authority over the custodians can override the custodial process itself when the confined person still controls the appointments.

4. Delivered-Goods Populism Excuses Corruption

   Long's hold on voters rested on tangible, countable benefits such as old-age pensions, free textbooks, roads and hospitals. Poor voters could weigh these directly against reform candidates' abstract promises of clean government. Voters knowingly accept graft and buffoonery as the price of a politician who reliably delivers, which is why Long could quip that if Louisiana ever got good government, its people wouldn't like it.

Save and mark ideas in the app