Cover of Picture

Picture

Lillian Ross

4 ideas

  1. Director Leaves Before Final Cut

    John Huston shot The Red Badge of Courage, then left for Africa to make The African Queen before editing and previews were finished. An artist's leverage over a work depends on physically staying through the stage where it can still be changed.

  2. Preview Cards Override Artistic Intent

    After a poor test screening, MGM treated the audience comment cards as a verdict rather than one data point among many. The studio responded by cutting the film to about 69 minutes, dropping scenes, and adding a voice-over narration that explained what the images had been left to imply. When a system fears commercial failure, it lets its least engaged viewers' reactions dictate the structure of a work.

  3. The Film as Executive Chess Piece

    Production chief Dore Schary championed the film, Louis B. Mayer opposed it, and New York president Nicholas Schenck approved it so the young Schary could learn a lesson, whatever the outcome. Seen this way, the picture was mostly a token in a contest over who ran the studio, not an artistic project to be judged on its merits. In layered hierarchies, a project's fate is often settled by what it signals in power struggles above it.

  4. Self-Indictment Through Uncommented Reportage

    Ross records scenes and verbatim dialogue, orders them like a novel, and adds almost no authorial judgment. The subjects' own words and choices, placed next to one another, expose the system's vanity, fear, and self-deception more effectively than editorializing could. The reporter's argument lives in selection and sequence, not in stated opinion.

Save and mark ideas in the app