Cover of The Adversary

The Adversary

France · 1975–1993

7 ideas

Buy on Amazon

Carrère's account of Jean-Claude Romand, who posed as a doctor for eighteen years before killing his family, and of the writer's own uneasy fascination with him.

  1. Romand's eighteen-year fake doctor life

    In 1975 Jean-Claude Romand failed to show up for his second-year medical exam, then told his family he had passed. For eighteen years he pretended to be a researcher at the WHO in Geneva, spending his days in cafés, parked cars and forests, and living on money that relatives had given him to 'invest'. In January 1993, with the funds nearly gone and exposure close, he killed his wife, his two children and his parents, then attempted suicide and survived.

  2. The single lie that compounds irreversibly

    One small initial lie, a claim to have sat an exam he skipped, grows into a whole false identity because each day of keeping it up raises the cost of confessing. The deception needs no grand plan, only the repeated postponement of admission, until the only exits left are exposure or destruction.

  3. The void behind the social mask

    Romand's everyday life had no content under the performance. Seen this way, the monstrous figure is less an evil agent than an absence that other people's belief kept going, which is why his motive stays unreadable even to himself.

  4. The writer's fascination implicates the writer

    Carrère argues that he cannot write honestly about Romand without facing why the case draws him: his own fear of being a fraud and his own gap between inner emptiness and public role. He also argues that Romand's late religious conversion may be one more self-deception, so any storyteller who supplies Romand with an inner truth risks joining the lie. He resolves this by writing in the first person and admitting his own uncertainty.

  5. The lie that forecloses its own confession

    A small initial lie, such as not admitting to a missed exam, becomes harder to retract with each day it survives, because confessing would now mean revealing every day of lying, not just the original act. The cost of the truth grows faster than the cost of the next lie, so the deceiver keeps building until the only way left to avoid discovery is to destroy the people who would discover it.

  6. The empty centre behind the mask

    Investigators and the author looked for a hidden double life behind Romand's fake career, such as espionage, trafficking or a secret identity, and found nothing: his days were spent idling and waiting. Seen this way, the false self was not a cover for a real self but a replacement for one. The mask had nothing behind it, and that emptiness is more disturbing than any secret would have been.

  7. The narrator cannot stand outside the monster

    Carrère abandoned his attempts to write from inside Romand's head or as a detached observer. Instead he wrote in the first person about his own fascination and his possible complicity in giving Romand the audience he craved. He argues that an honest account of such a person must also question the teller's motives, including his doubt about whether Romand's prison conversion to Christianity was sincere or simply one more performance.

Save ideas and give them a thumbs up or down in the app