Cover of Justine

Justine

France · 1775–1788

4 ideas

Buy on Amazon

In France, Justine tries to remain virtuous through sexual violence and other abuses. The libertines who harm her argue that nature offers virtue no reward. De Sade sets her resolve against their arguments, making her story a harsh test of the belief that good conduct will be rewarded.

  1. Justine's virtue repeatedly rewarded with ruin

    Two orphaned sisters take opposite paths. Each charitable act sets up her next punishment, and when Juliette finally rescues her, Justine is killed by a stray bolt of lightning.

  2. Destruction is nature's work, not crime

    The libertines argue that nature creates only through destruction. Killing therefore merely returns matter to circulation in another form, so it cannot offend nature and may even serve it. On this view, crime is a category invented by human law, not something found in the natural order.

  3. Morality is a weapon of the weak

    Laws, pity, and conscience are conventions the weak invented to restrain the strong, who owe them no natural obligation. The libertines treat each person's pleasure as the only real measure, dismissing others' suffering as a sensation that is not one's own. On this account, compassion is a learned weakness rather than a natural instinct.

  4. Virtue only pays when others share it

    Honesty and charity work like a cooperative strategy. They benefit you only in a society where most people practice them. Among predators, the virtuous person becomes the easiest target, because her trust, pity, and refusal to retaliate are exactly what others exploit.

Save ideas and give them a thumbs up or down in the app