If This Is a Man

4 ideas

1. The Drowned and the Saved

   The camp divided prisoners into those who went under within weeks, the exhausted and passive 'Muselmänner' who followed the rules and ate only the official ration, and those who survived by 'organizing', which meant trading, stealing, finding privileged posts, or adapting their morals to camp law. Because the camp removed every normal buffer of family, law, and mutual aid, the ordinary middle ground between success and failure disappeared, and small differences in cunning, health, skill or luck grew into the difference between death and survival. The saved were therefore not the best: survival often required giving up the ethics of the outside world.

2. The Icicle and 'Hier ist kein warum'

   Soon after arriving at Monowitz, the thirsty Levi reached out of a barrack window and broke off an icicle to suck. A guard immediately snatched it from him. When Levi asked 'Warum?' ('Why?'), the guard shoved him back and answered 'Hier ist kein warum' ('Here there is no why'), which taught Levi on his first day that the camp's rules existed to deny the prisoner any claim to reasons.

3. Washing as refusal of consent

   Steinlauf, a former sergeant of the Austro-Hungarian army, scrubbed himself daily in filthy water with no soap and told Levi that this was not about hygiene. The camp was a machine for reducing people to beasts, and the prisoner's last power was to refuse his consent by keeping the outward forms of civilization: washing, walking upright, blacking one's shoes. By keeping the form, the prisoner keeps the self that the form expresses.

4. Doktor Pannwitz's aquarium-glass gaze

   When Levi sat a chemistry exam to qualify for the Buna laboratory, the examiner Dr. Pannwitz looked up at him with a gaze that Levi said passed 'as if through the glass of an aquarium between two beings who live in different worlds.' Levi reads that look as the core of the whole system. It was not hatred but a cold classification that measured whether this specimen was worth using before disposing of it, so that genocide could run as ordinary, competent administration.

Save and mark ideas in the app