Cover of Historia de la nación chichimeca

Historia de la nación chichimeca

Mexico · 12th century – 16th century

4 ideas

Buy on Amazon

A chronicle of the Chichimec peoples and Texcoco's kingdom by a descendant of its rulers, arguing that Texcocan allies helped win the conquest of Tenochtitlan and that the Spanish Crown owes his lineage recognition.

  1. Ixtlilxóchitl's Texcocan army at Tenochtitlan's fall

    After losing the Texcocan succession to his brother Cacama, whom Moctezuma backed, the prince Ixtlilxóchitl allied with Cortés, was baptized as Hernando, and brought Texcoco's forces to the Spanish side. The book uses this case to argue that a dynastic dispute inside the Aztec Triple Alliance, not Spanish arms alone, brought down Tenochtitlan.

  2. Conquest as Indigenous civil war, not foreign victory

    Alva Ixtlilxóchitl argues that a few hundred Spaniards could not have taken Tenochtitlan without Indigenous allies. The conquest succeeded because local rulers used the invaders to settle their own grievances against the Mexica hegemon. On this view, credit for the victory belongs largely to the native allies, which shifts who can claim it.

  3. Service rendered creates a standing claim

    The chronicle is built like a petition of merits. It documents specific services an ancestor gave the Crown, such as troops, labor, loyalty and conversion, and treats them as a debt the sovereign owes the lineage in lands, titles and privileges. History writing here works as legal evidence: whoever narrates the past controls who is owed in the present.

  4. Presenting the pre-Christian past as proto-Christian

    The book presents Nezahualcóyotl as a philosopher-king, lawgiver and poet who worshipped a single invisible 'Lord of the Near and Close' and built a temple without idols. By making his ancestors appear already reasonable, just and nearly monotheistic, the mestizo author makes the Indigenous nobility worthy of honor under colonial Catholic values. The same lens applies wherever a subordinated group translates its heritage into the dominant culture's moral vocabulary to win status.

Save ideas and give them a thumbs up or down in the app