Cover of En el día de hoy

En el día de hoy

Spain · 1939–1940

4 ideas

Buy on Amazon

Spain, around 1939: in Torbado’s alternate history, the Republic wins the Civil War and Franco goes into exile. The novel follows the political aftermath of that reversal, asking how the victors might govern a country still divided by war.

  1. Republican victory with Franco in exile

    Torbado's 1976 Premio Planeta novel imagines the Second Spanish Republic winning the Civil War in 1939, with Franco fleeing into exile, and follows postwar Spain under the victorious Republic. The title inverts the opening words of the Nationalists' final war communiqué of 1 April 1939 ('En el día de hoy, cautivo y desarmado el Ejército Rojo...'), assigning that proclamation of total victory to the other side.

  2. Civil war victors inherit the same logic

    The novel suggests that whichever faction wins a civil war faces the same pressures: consolidating power, settling scores with the defeated, and suppressing rivals inside its own coalition. Swapping the winner does not remove the postwar machinery of purges and exclusion, because that machinery comes from total victory in a fratricidal war, not from any one ideology.

  3. Counterfactual history as critique of present

    Written just after Franco's death, during the transition, an imagined Republican victory works as a mirror for the real Francoist settlement. By showing the other side's triumph, it makes readers see that the actual outcome was contingent, not inevitable, and invites them to judge both regimes by the same standard.

  4. Interchangeable rhetoric of official victory

    Borrowing Franco's victory communiqué for a Republican triumph shows that the formulas of official victory, such as the defeated enemy and the war declared over, carry no content of their own. Any regime can fill them in. Language that presents itself as the voice of history is really a template the winner occupies.

Save ideas and give them a thumbs up or down in the app