Cover of De Divinatione

De Divinatione

Ancient Rome · 44 BCE

4 ideas

Buy on Amazon

A dialogue in which Cicero's brother defends Roman divination on Stoic grounds and Cicero refutes it as an Academic Skeptic, arguing that forecasts must be tested against outcomes and that augury serves the state.

  1. Hits are remembered, misses are forgotten

    Cicero argues that the apparent success of divination comes from selective memory: people record and retell the predictions that came true while the far larger number of failed ones vanish unremarked. When a practice makes many forecasts, some will hit by chance, so a list of successes proves nothing without the count of failures.

  2. Divination has no domain of its own

    Cicero argues that for any question, a specialist skill already gives a better answer: physicians for illness, pilots for weather, generals for war. If a matter can be known by skill, divination is unnecessary, and if it is truly a matter of chance, no art can foresee it, so divination has no work left to do.

  3. Stoic argument from providence to divination

    Quintus's Stoic case runs as a chain: gods exist, gods care for humans, caring gods would give humans signs of the future, and humans can learn to read those signs; the apparent working of divination is also offered as evidence the gods exist. Cicero's reply disputes the premises and argues that the implications do not follow.

  4. Divination as a tool of political control

    Cicero, himself an augur, admits that augury is kept up for the state's benefit and for public belief, not because it reveals truth. Seen this way, omens act as a procedural lever: officials can announce bad signs to delay assemblies or block laws. The question then shifts from whether the ritual is true to who controls it.

Save ideas and give them a thumbs up or down in the app