Crime and Punishment

Fyodor Dostoevsky

4 ideas

1. Raskolnikov's axe murder and eventual confession

   An impoverished ex-student in 1860s St Petersburg kills the old pawnbroker Alyona Ivanovna with an axe. When her gentle half-sister Lizaveta walks in unexpectedly, he kills her too. He takes only a few trinkets and a purse, hides them under a stone without ever using them, and then falls into fever, paranoia and self-betrayal. Urged on by Sonya, a young woman driven into prostitution to feed her family, he kneels in the Haymarket, confesses to the police, and is sentenced to eight years of penal servitude in Siberia.

2. Raskolnikov's theory of the extraordinary man

   In his article 'On Crime', Raskolnikov divides humanity into ordinary people, who must obey the law, and extraordinary people like Napoleon, who have an inner right to step over moral barriers, including blood, if their idea demands it. After the murder he tells Sonya that his need to test the theory, and his doubts about it, show he was never one of the extraordinary. The novel presents this as Raskolnikov's own verdict on himself, not as proof that his division of humanity holds.

3. Let the guilty suspect stay free

   The magistrate Porfiry deliberately withholds arrest when he lacks hard evidence. A suspect left at liberty, and left unsure how much the investigator knows, cannot stop circling back toward the investigator and exposing himself, like a moth drawn to a candle. Porfiry uses indirect conversation, feigned carelessness and hints so that the suspect's own mind does the work of cross-examination.

4. Punishment begins inside, as isolation

   Before any court acts, Raskolnikov experiences his crime as being severed from other people: he cannot bear his mother's and sister's love or speak honestly to anyone. Sonya's reading of the raising of Lazarus points him toward confession as a way back to life, but confessing does not make him repentant. Only later, in Siberia, does his love for Sonya begin to open him to renewal.

Save and mark ideas in the app