Broad and Alien Is the World

3 ideas

1. Rumi loses its land in court

   In the Peruvian Andes, the landowner Álvaro Amenábar sues the indigenous community of Rumi over its boundaries. With bought witnesses, a lawyer for the comuneros who betrays them, and written proceedings the comuneros cannot read, he wins the fertile valley, and the community is pushed onto the barren heights of Yanañahui. Their mayor Rosendo Maqui is jailed on a false charge and dies after a beating in prison; the scattered comuneros later make a last armed stand that is crushed by troops.

2. Taking land to capture labor

   The hacendado wants more than the soil. He wants landless comuneros who must become peons on his estate or workers in his mine. When a community loses its common land, it loses the independence that let it refuse wage and debt labor. Read this way, a property dispute is really a fight over who can be made to work for whom.

3. Communal tenure as the social fabric

   In Rumi, shared land holds the whole community together. It sustains collective work, the authority of elders, mutual aid and a shared identity. When the land goes, the people scatter as individuals to rubber forests, coca plantations, mines and cities, and they are exploited one by one. The novel shows that the community cannot survive without the commons.

Save and mark ideas in the app