Cover of Bread Givers

Bread Givers

United States · 1910–1925

4 ideas

Buy on Amazon

On New York’s Lower East Side in the early twentieth century, Sara Smolinsky grows up in a poor Jewish immigrant household ruled by her father. She wants to earn her own living and study, and his authority stands in her way. Bread Givers makes that struggle concrete through a family’s daily need for money.

  1. Sara Smolinsky's escape from her father's house

    Reb Smolinsky, a Talmud scholar on the Lower East Side, does no paid work and lives off his wife's and daughters' wages. He drives off his older daughters' chosen suitors and matches them to men who ruin them: Bessie to a widowed fish peddler, Mashah to a fake diamond dealer, Fania to a gambler. At seventeen Sara, the youngest, leaves home, irons in a laundry, studies at night, works her way through college and becomes a teacher.

  2. Sacred male scholarship runs on female labor

    The father's claim to holiness depends on an economic arrangement. His Torah study is funded by the wages of the women in his house. The same religious doctrine that ranks him above them also says a woman reaches heaven only through a father or husband. Piety works as a way to take their labor while calling the taking a spiritual order.

  3. Daughters as assets in marriage trades

    In a household where a daughter's value is her earning power or her marriage prospects, the father treats her choice of husband as a transaction he controls. He rejects suitors who might free her from him and chooses men who seem to bring money or status.

  4. Escape leaves the inherited burden intact

    Winning independence from a controlling origin does not end the relationship to it. It changes the terms on which you carry it. Sara's professional, assimilated life gives her freedom, but it also costs her years of isolation. She still feels the pull of duty toward the father she fled, and the old world's weight comes back as an obligation she chooses rather than one forced on her.

Save ideas and give them a thumbs up or down in the app