Cover of A Question of Madness

A Question of Madness

Russia · 1970

3 ideas

Buy on Amazon

Two brothers document the 1970 forced psychiatric committal of biologist Zhores Medvedev for his dissident writings. He gives the view from inside the hospital and Roy the campaign outside that freed him.

  1. Zhores Medvedev's Nineteen Days in Kaluga

    On 29 May 1970, police and psychiatrists removed Soviet biologist Zhores Medvedev from his home in Obninsk and committed him to the Kaluga psychiatric hospital. The pretext was his writings, including his history of the Lysenko affair and his exposé of Soviet censorship of scientists' mail. He was released on 17 June, after his brother Roy led a pressure campaign and prominent figures including Andrei Sakharov, Pyotr Kapitsa and Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn protested publicly.

  2. Dissent Rewritten as a Psychiatric Symptom

    Punitive psychiatry turns political nonconformity into a medical diagnosis. Labels such as a 'split personality' for a scientist who also writes social criticism, or 'poor adaptation to the social environment', recast the content of dissent as evidence of illness. Once the critic is classed as sick, the state can detain him indefinitely without a trial, without charges and without having to answer his arguments.

  3. Dual Testimony From Inside and Outside

    The book tells one detention twice. Zhores records the institution from within: the interviews, the diagnostic manoeuvres and the doctors' uncertainty. Roy records the campaign from outside: the phone calls, the letters and the officials who dodged responsibility. Setting the two accounts side by side shows repression as a system with an internal process and an external negotiation, which neither account could show alone.

Save ideas and give them a thumbs up or down in the app