Cover of Shamans, software, and spleens

Shamans, software, and spleens

18th century – 20th century

6 ideas

Buy on Amazon

A legal theorist examines intellectual property in the information society. He argues that law favors the romantic author over sources and calls for an environmentalism of information to defend the public domain.

  1. The romantic author shapes IP law

    Boyle argues intellectual property law leans on the ideal of the original, transformative author as the source of value. This construct rewards composers and inventors while ignoring the sources they draw on.

  2. Information as the central commodity

    The information society makes control over information the key economic and legal battleground, from genes to software to data. Old property categories strain to fit intangible information.

  3. Moore v. Regents and the spleen

    John Moore's cancerous spleen cells were patented without his consent, yet courts denied him property in his own tissue. The case exposes who gets ownership when value is extracted from a person.

  4. The author-source asymmetry

    Legal reward flows to those framed as transformative authors, not to the sources whose raw material they use. The asymmetry recurs across genetics, indigenous knowledge, and blackmail law.

  5. We need an environmentalism of information

    Boyle calls for a coalition politics to defend the public domain, analogous to environmentalism defending the commons. Without it, enclosure of information proceeds by default.

  6. The baseline problem in property

    Deciding what counts as raw public material versus privately added value requires a baseline the law never neutrally supplies. Every IP allocation smuggles in a contestable starting point.

Save ideas and give them a thumbs up or down in the app